These photographs come from different moments in 1917. Their captions preserve those distinctions: June meetings and July violence are not the October takeover, and October in the Russian calendar can mean November elsewhere. None of these images is presented as a photograph of the storming of the Winter Palace.
Topic: Russian Revolution and Bolshevik seizure of power
01 / 06
An armed group in the revolutionary capital
Red Guards gather in Petrograd during the autumn of 1917. The source identifies the season, not November 7 itself. Rifles, uniforms and civilian clothing share the frame. This is a contemporary group photograph, not a photograph of the capture of the Winter Palace.
Photo details
Date
Autumn 1917
Location
Petrograd, Russia (now Saint Petersburg)
Photographer
Unknown photographer
Archive / collection
Historical photograph reproduced in a 1920s book; scan via Wikimedia Commons
Unknown photographer / Historical photograph reproduced in a 1920s book; scan via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain; Commons Public Domain Mark
02 / 06
A council before the takeover
This photograph is cataloged as a meeting of soldiers’ deputies at the Tauride Palace in June 1917. It records the crowded institutional politics of the revolutionary year. It should not be confused with the later congress associated with the Bolshevik seizure of power.
Unknown photographer / Historical photograph via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain in Russia and the United States; expired historical photograph
03 / 06
The July crisis leaves a mark
A shop window displays a bullet hole after the July disturbances in Petrograd. The Library of Congress preserves the photograph without naming its photographer. This small piece of street damage belongs to the summer crisis, months before the November takeover.
Unknown photographer / Library of Congress, cph.3b41906, LCCN91789618. Public domain; Library of Congress notes no copyright restriction
04 / 06
Lenin in disguise
Dmitry Leshchenko photographed Lenin wearing a wig and cap at Razliv on August 11, 1917 (July 29 in the Julian calendar). It belongs to the months before the Bolsheviks took power, and its modest dimensions reflect the published archival copy.
Photo details
Date
August 11, 1917 Gregorian / July 29 Julian
Location
Razliv, near Petrograd, Russia
Photographer
Dmitry Ilyich Leshchenko
Archive / collection
Lenin: Collection of Photographs and Stills, volume 1, 1970, page 46; via Wikimedia Commons
Dmitry Ilyich Leshchenko / Lenin: Collection of Photographs and Stills, volume 1, 1970, page 46; via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain; historical photograph (Commons PD-Russia)
05 / 06
At the entrance to Smolny
Pyotr Novitsky photographed the entrance to Smolny in the revolutionary autumn. The source labels it October 1917 without resolving the calendar convention. The building was associated with the revolutionary leadership; armed guards and a machine gun stand on the entrance steps.
Photo details
Date
Autumn 1917; source labels October
Location
Petrograd, Russia (now Saint Petersburg)
Photographer
Pyotr Novitsky
Archive / collection
Russia in Photo; reproduction via Wikimedia Commons
Pyotr Novitsky / Russia in Photo; reproduction via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain in Russia and the United States; expired historical photograph
06 / 06
Checking papers on the street
Yakov Steinberg’s photograph shows Red Guards checking documents. The source explicitly dates the scene to November 1917 in the Gregorian calendar, corresponding to October in the Julian calendar. It records street-level control during the revolutionary period; the exact day is not supplied.
Photo details
Date
November 1917 Gregorian / October 1917 Julian
Location
Petrograd, Russia (now Saint Petersburg)
Photographer
Yakov Vladimirovich Steinberg
Archive / collection
Russia in Photo; reproduction via Wikimedia Commons
Yakov Vladimirovich Steinberg / Russia in Photo; reproduction via Wikimedia Commons. Public domain in Russia and the United States; expired historical photograph